What Is a Chargeback?

senior man talking on smartphone and holding credit card

What is a Chargeback?

Chargebacks are a crucial safeguard that helps to boost public trust in credit and debit card payments, particularly in online purchases. They may, however, be a major issue for merchants who must deal with them. Many consumers challenge transactions that do not fit within the short list of issues that chargebacks are meant to solve, or they register a dispute without first contacting the merchant.

The general number of chargebacks is growing yearly, and the coronavirus pandemic resulted in a significant increase in disputes in 2020 and 2021. As the number of chargebacks has risen, more firms are taking steps to avoid and combat them.

What are chargebacks, and what should retailers know to prevent and combat them as efficiently as possible?

A chargeback is a credit card or or credit card transaction that the cardholder’s bank reverses when the cardholder disputes a charge on their account. Payment disputes are another term for chargebacks.

The definition of the term chargeback is easy. The bank will charge back to the merchant the amount of the disputed transaction, returning the funds to the cardholder without the business’s agreement.

When a cardholder rejects a charge, banks normally evaluate the transaction and, if the basis for the dispute is genuine, credit the customer’s account provisionally until the chargeback claim is handled.

Chargebacks were a direct response to massive theft by fraudsters who could exploit and misuse stolen credit information with no recourse for the consumer.

Consider the following: When a credit card is misplaced or stolen, it is utilised to make fraudulent purchases. Without a Chargeback, the cardholder would have little or no recourse to recover their money once the merchant had been paid.

The chargeback method allows consumers to receive reimbursements from their banks while also allowing banks (rather than cardholders and merchants) to make judgements about how to handle the matter. While the procedure was not then known as a chargeback, it would establish the cornerstone for the modern dispute system.

What is the procedure for chargebacks?

Cardholders begin chargeback cases, which are then reviewed by banks and paid for by merchants. From start to finish, a single chargeback might take months or even years.

While banks may submit chargebacks for reasons such as authorisation or processing issues, the vast prevalence of chargebacks occur when a consumer contacts their card provider or bank to dispute a charge on their account. They usually do this because they don’t recognise the charge and suspect it is fraudulent.

However, in other circumstances, a cardholder may dispute a charge because they believe they did not receive what they paid for and the merchant has refused to fix the issue.

Once a chargeback is begun, it will effectively travel to and from the issuing bank and the merchant until either one of them accepts culpability or the card network is brought in to resolve the issue.

What is the distinction between a section 75 and a chargeback claim?

Section 75 can only be used on credit cards for purchases between £100 and £30,000. Chargeback can be utilised for any amount on your debit, credit, or prepaid cards.

A Section 75 claim is established in law, which means your card issuer bears equal duty with the shop for assuring the quality of your products or services.

Chargeback, on the other hand, is a voluntary arrangement between card providers and issuers such as Visa, Mastercard, and American Express.

Because it is legally enforceable, Section 75 normally provides you a higher chance of getting your money back, although chargeback might be a beneficial alternative if Section 75 does not apply.

What exactly is the chargeback process?

The chargeback process begins with the merchant’s decision to accept or dispute the chargeback through representation. The issuing bank evaluates the merchant’s proof and either reverses or upholds the chargeback in representation. Most chargebacks finish here, however there are certain exceptions.

  • When a cardholder files a chargeback request with their issuing bank, the bank determines whether or not the client has grounds to do so.
  • If a chargeback is approved, the bank will contact the acquiring bank (also known as the merchant’s bank) and deduct the monies from the merchant’s account.
  • The business can accept the chargeback or argue it by resubmitting the charge with a rebuttal letter and the relevant proof to refute the accusation. This is known as representation.
  • The issuing bank will consider the additional evidence before making a judgement. The payments will be reimbursed if they find in favour of the merchant.
  • At this stage, any party who is dissatisfied with the decision can fight it further by requesting pre-arbitration. This usually happens when the issuing bank makes a judgement in favour of the merchant but later gets fresh evidence that calls that decision into doubt.
  • If neither side acknowledges blame during the pre-arbitration period, the chargeback is sent to arbitration. The card network will review the facts and make a final determination here. This ruling cannot be challenged any further, and the losing side must pay hundreds of thousands in costs.
  • The amount of time businesses have to reply to a dispute varies depending on the credit card network and the reason code. Because the timeframe starts when the chargeback is begun rather than when the merchant is alerted, the merchant’s deadline may differ from the time limit specified by the card network’s regulations.

What are the implications of chargebacks for merchants?

When fees and other charges are considered, chargebacks can result in a revenue loss of up to double the transaction value for retailers. They also boost the merchant’s chargeback percentage, which might have major ramifications.

If a merchant’s chargeback ratio surpasses specific levels set by card networks and other financial institutions with which they do business, they may suffer fines, increased chargeback costs, and even account termination. The most often used threshold is 1%, however, Visa recently reduced it to 0.9%.

How many chargebacks occur each year?

Chargeback information is often shared solely with the parties involved, and the card networks appear uninterested in disclosing any data they have. As a result, detailed statistics on the number of chargebacks is impossible to get.

We also know that chargebacks are increasing year after year. Aite Group anticipated in 2018 that the total amount of chargebacks would reach $35 billion by 2021, and considering the spike in disputes that preceded the COVID-19 outbreak, it’s not surprising that we’ve already well beyond that figure.

How do you go about filing a chargeback?

It is not recommended, and in certain situations illegal, to file a chargeback without first consulting the seller. If you’ve previously sought to resolve the issue with the merchant without success, just contact your bank and request that the transaction be disputed.

Typically, the bank will provide you with a temporary credit for the amount of the charge while they investigate the claim’s authenticity. Prepare to detail your interactions with the merchant and the efforts you took to fix the issue.

Customers submit chargebacks for a variety of reasons

Customers frequently submit chargebacks when they don’t recognise a transaction or are unhappy with their purchase. As friendly fraud grows increasingly common, it’s vital to remember that the consumer may simply be attempting to acquire something for free in some circumstances.

Examining the reason code on the chargeback might assist you figure out why a consumer challenged a transaction.

A reason code is assigned to each chargeback. These codes were developed by the main card networks (Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express) to clearly indicate the basis for a chargeback request.

What do chargeback reason codes mean?

Chargeback reason codes notify retailers about why a client is contesting a charge based on the information they submitted to their bank. Each reason code is coupled with a set of proof and evidence requirements that decide whether or not the chargeback is justified.

Because they don’t recognise the name of the firm mentioned in their account, some consumers may mistakenly believe that a charge on their account was unlawful. Others may have neglected to pay a reoccurring fee that they committed to.

Some consumers want to submit a chargeback because of a bad experience they had with the retailer, but they realise the reason they have isn’t valid. To get the chargeback, they lie to the bank about the cause for the request. In rare circumstances, a consumer may have made a purchase with the goal of subsequently falsely contesting the charge in order to recover their money.

When is it legal for a cardholder to challenge a charge?

Chargebacks are not something that cardholders can simply utilise if they don’t like anything they bought. There is often just one circumstance in which a cardholder should contact a bank first for chargebacks: genuine fraud.

If a cardholder is the victim of actual fraud (card theft, identity theft, etc.), a chargeback is not only legal, but also the ethical way for the issuing bank and the merchant to settle the problem.

Customers can also submit chargebacks if they did not receive the goods or service for which they paid, whether due to a missing or damaged shipment or an erroneous item being supplied.

Another reasonable ground for a disagreement is being charged twice or more than the agreed-upon purchase price.

Problems like this, however, are generally handled more quickly and simply when the client approaches the retailer, and a chargeback should only be utilised when the merchant is unwilling to cooperate.

The term “chargeback” has several connotations depending on the activities of the cardholder. The term is commonly used to infer chargebacks for actual fraud, however some consumers perpetrate “friendly fraud” by initiating a chargeback for no legitimate cause.

Customers cannot contest a fee just because they are unhappy with the goods or service they got. These concerns must always be dealt directly with the merchant.

What are the three different kinds of chargebacks?

True fraud, friendly fraud, and merchant error are the three categories of chargebacks. Each category is the product of various circumstances and should be addressed differently. Friendly fraud is the most prevalent sort of chargeback, accounting for 60% to 80% of all chargebacks.

True Fraud

True fraud chargebacks are what chargebacks were designed to address: illegal transactions made to a credit card by a scammer or identity thief. Merchants should avoid wasting time or money attempting to contest these chargebacks.

True fraud chargebacks are best avoided by using fraud protection software. The basic minimum is AVS and CVV matching, but many merchants additionally utilise 3-D Secure 2.0 or third-party solutions that use machine learning to try to screen out fraudulent transactions.

Friendly Fraud

Friendly fraud chargebacks occur when customers report legitimate charges as fraudulent in order to have the payment reversed. They may do this on purpose, with malevolent or illegal intent, or out of impatience or bewilderment. Friendly fraud chargebacks are frequently misidentified as actual fraud chargebacks, with the client erroneously stating they did not approve the payment.

These chargebacks are difficult to prevent, but they can be challenged in court to recoup lost money. Customers who file favourable fraud chargebacks may be banned as well.

Merchant Error

Merchant error chargebacks arise when the chargeback is the result of a merchant error, such as sending the incorrect goods. Disputes like these can occasionally be successfully defended, but the weaknesses in merchant processes that these chargebacks expose must be addressed to avoid similar future chargebacks.

Chargebacks due to merchant mistake may be avoided by strengthening business procedures, having easily accessible and excellent customer care, and having a substantial refund policy.

Who is responsible for chargebacks?

In most circumstances, merchants are accountable for chargebacks and have the burden of evidence in any disagreement. A merchant must argue why a chargeback should be overturned. If the merchant takes no action, the cardholder wins by default.

If a card-present merchant makes a purchase with an EMV chip and the transaction is fraudulent, the issuing bank is held accountable rather than the retailer. Chargebacks resulting from merchant mistakes are still the merchant’s responsibility.

Should merchants challenge chargebacks?

If a chargeback appears to be fraudulent, retailers should fight back through representation whenever feasible. Though a consumer may allege that a transaction was fraudulent, merchants frequently have the documentation necessary to show otherwise, thereby allowing them to recoup their losses.

Merchants who get an unjustified chargeback have the opportunity to fight the matter. To do so, they must first write a rebuttal letter arguing their position, as well as a number of supporting papers and proof. The type of proof required will be determined by the reason code connected with the chargeback.

When a merchant challenges a cardholder chargeback, it enters the representation stage. During this procedure, the retailer offers details about the transaction and why they feel it was legal.

Learn How To Fight Them! The merchant works with their sales. The Smart Way department and/or their chargeback management provider will create a dispute package outlining the facts and attempting to persuade the issuing bank in accordance with the requirements of that bank.

Following that, the acquiring bank transmits the information back to the issuing bank via the credit card network, which takes a decision and notifies the parties involved.

If you intend to fight a chargeback, you must move promptly. Because issuers sometimes wait in alerting acquirers and merchants of chargebacks, you may have a very little window in which to respond. Having a chargeback representation staff at your disposal may help you move quickly and efficiently, regardless of the deadline.

How should a chargeback reply letter be written?

You can write a letter or submit a form including your dispute information package, depending on the credit or payment provider. A rebuttal letter sums up your position and responds to the cardholder’s complaint.

A fast response letter will assist you in better dealing with false chargebacks and winning disputes. A rebuttal letter, when done correctly, gives a straightforward explanation of why the customer’s assertions are untrue and what evidence you have to support it. When challenging friendly fraud chargebacks, a strong reply letter backed up by appropriate proof will usually persuade the issuing bank to find in your favour and recover your revenue.

Can you stop all chargebacks?

Not every disagreement can be avoided. Some are the consequence of true criminal conduct, while others are the result of errors or oversights on the part of the merchant. Merchants may decrease chargebacks by up to 70% if adequate precautions are adopted.

Studying and battling disputes can help you understand why they’re occurring to you, and resolving those core problems is by far the most effective way to avoid future chargebacks.

How much do chargeback fees cost?

Depending on your acquiring bank, chargeback costs generally vary from £20 to £100. The real cost of a chargeback, on the other hand, is frequently up to 2.5 times the transaction value. As a result, a merchant would pay £250 in fees, penalties, client acquisition costs, and other expenses for a £100 chargeback.

Chargebacks might jeopardise your cash flow and jeopardise your merchant accounts. They can raise your merchant account fees or cause your accounts to be closed, prohibiting you from receiving payments.

Understand the facts regarding chargebacks.

When you know what chargebacks are, you can combat them more effectively, learn from them, and take preventative measures. Even if you hire a chargeback management service to handle them for you, knowing the facts regarding chargebacks can help you determine whether that firm is giving you a decent return on your investment.

What is the UK Law Regarding Chargebacks?

In the United Kingdom credit card chargebacks are governed by the Consumer Credit Act of 1974 and the Consumer Rights Act of 2015.

A chargeback occurs when a customer requests a credit card company to undo a previously authorised transaction. This is an option for consumers who are unhappy with their purchases or who believe they are the victims of fraud.

Credit card chargebacks are permitted by the Consumer Credit Act of 1974 for limited time periods following the original purchase. To give you an idea, a customer has up to 120 days to challenge a charge for goods or services, and up to 540 days to contest a cash advance or ATM withdrawal.

In addition, if a customer feels they have been the victim of fraud or that the quality of the products or services they have received is subpar, they have the right to request a chargeback under the Consumer Rights Act 2015.

A chargeback can be requested by contacting the credit card company in question and providing supporting documents (such as receipts) in order to verify the validity of the consumer’s claim. After investigating, the credit card company will cancel the transaction and give a refund if the customer’s allegation is validated.

Credit card chargebacks are not guaranteed, and the card issuer might refuse to reimburse you if it finds that the original payment was legitimate. The Financial Ombudsman Service may be an alternative for the consumer to pursue in such situations.

Consumers in the United Kingdom have the legal right to dispute charges made to their credit cards if they are dissatisfied with the products or services they have received or if they suspect they are the victims of fraud. Consumers are better protected from unethical business practises by these rules, which also ensure that everyone is treated equitably by retailers and credit card companies.

Frequently Asked Questions about Chargebacks

What exactly is the distinction between a chargeback and a refund?

A chargeback can happen when a cardholder contacts their issuing bank to have a transaction reversed. In the case of a refund, the client contacts the merchant first, and then the merchant can start a return payment, avoiding the costs and other implications of chargebacks.

How much time do you have to argue against a chargeback?

A merchant has between 7 and 30 days to react to a chargeback, depending on the card network. If the merchant does not answer by the deadline, they will automatically lose by default and may be charged an extra cost.

What exactly is a chargeback threshold?

The most frequent chargeback threshold is 1%, which is computed as a ratio of chargebacks to total transactions. Merchants who exceed their chargeback threshold may incur penalties, including account termination.



Table of Contents

More from Vendreo